Dr No entitlement
Prevention principle is not a guaranteed route to relief
The panel explored whether employer-caused delay automatically relieves a contractor from its obligations. While the prevention principle prevents an employer from holding a contractor to an obligation it has itself obstructed, entitlement to additional costs will ultimately depend on the contractual provisions.
Delay claims are won through proactive contract administration
The panel emphasised the importance of timely notices, extension of time applications, programme analysis and contemporaneous records, instead of a "wait-and-see" approach often adopted by contractors.
Heavily amended contracts continue to drive construction disputes
Many disputes arise where standard form contracts have been extensively amended. The panel noted that amendments can distort the intended risk allocation and create uncertainty around issues such as concurrent delay, notices and entitlement.
NEC v FIDIC: Skyfall or success
NEC and FIDIC reflect different approaches to project delivery
NEC promotes collaboration, flexibility and proactive project management, while FIDIC focuses on clear risk allocation, detailed drafting and contractual certainty.
Risk management versus entitlement protection
NEC's early warning regime is designed to identify and manage risks before they escalate, whereas FIDIC's strength lies in providing clear contractual rights and evidential support when disputes arise.
Success depends on contract administration
Outcomes depend on how well the contract is operated in practice: FIDIC benefits from familiarity and established roles, while NEC rewards active administration and forward planning.
Live and let AI?
AI is here to stay, and professionals who embrace it will be best placed to succeed
The panel opened with a Q&A featuring "Tilly Norwood", an AI-generated actress, demonstrating how AI is becoming increasingly integrated into professional life and is not a future concept but a present reality. Professionals who understand and adopt it will gain a competitive advantage.
AI should enhance, not replace, professional expertise
While AI can automate routine tasks and increase efficiency, it cannot replace human judgement, commercial awareness or professional responsibility. Users of AI must remain accountable for reviewing AI-generated outputs.
Successful AI adoption requires training and governance
Successful adoption requires clear policies, approved tools, appropriate security measures and ongoing training. Understanding where AI adds value, and where human intervention is required, will be essential to maintaining quality and client trust.
No time to hide: Corporate group liability after the Building Safety Act (BSA)
Courts are taking a broad approach to liability under the BSA Recent cases such as Crest Nicholson v Ardmore and Mulalley demonstrate the courts' willingness to adopt a broad interpretation of the BSA, particularly where it is "just and equitable" to do so. For developers and corporate groups, liability may extend beyond the original contracting entity.
Insolvency and group structures no longer provide the protection they once did
Claimants are increasingly able to pursue associated companies through mechanisms such as Building Liability Orders. Corporate groups must therefore assess their wider exposure rather than focusing solely on project-specific entities.
Documentation and traceability are becoming the new battleground
The BSA’s long-term legacy may be greater accountability through improved record-keeping and accountability. Greater scrutiny of historic projects mean that parties will increasingly need clear evidence of who designed, approved and delivered key decisions.
Practical takeaways
- The prevention principle may step in to protect the contractor in cases of employer-caused delay, but does not in itself entitle the contractor to additional costs.
- The NEC and FIDIC standard contracts provide for two very different approaches to contracting and the choice should be carefully considered.
- AI can enhance efficiency, but users should ensure all outputs are reviewed using professional judgment.
- BSA liability can arise across the wider corporate group, not just the contracting entity.