• FCA
Choose your location?
  • Global Global
  • Australian flag Australia
  • Canadian flag Canada (FR)
  • French flag France
  • German flag Germany
  • Irish flag Ireland
  • Italian flag Italy
  • Polish flag Poland
  • Qatar flag Qatar
  • Spanish flag Spain
  • UAE flag UAE
  • UK flag UK
Cyber risk without borders

Cyber risk without borders: Navigating privacy, AI and regulation in a connected world

Risk Matters: The DWF insurance podcast | Ep11
Cyber risk is no longer just an IT issue. In this episode, DWF experts from Canada, the UK and France explore the rapidly evolving cyber, privacy and AI landscape, examining regulatory reform, supply chain vulnerabilities, emerging claims trends and the challenge of building resilience in an increasingly connected world.

Cyber risk is no longer confined by borders. As threats become more sophisticated and regulatory frameworks evolve, organisations are having to navigate an increasingly complex landscape of privacy, artificial intelligence and cyber security requirements across multiple jurisdictions.

In Part 1 of the latest episode of Risk Matters, host Mouna Hanna, Canadian Chair of DWF’s Cyber, Privacy and Data Protection team, is joined by Tim Smith, Partner in DWF’s Global Risks team, and Stéphanie Berland, Partner, France, to explore what these developments mean for businesses operating in an interconnected world.

The discussion examines the changing regulatory environment alongside the practical risks organisations face, from increasingly interconnected supply chains to major cyber incidents and business interruption exposures. The panel also considers emerging claims trends and how organisations can approach cyber risk when their operations, customers and regulatory obligations span different jurisdictions.

Key areas covered include the EU Digital Omnibus reforms, developments surrounding GDPR and data subject access requests, and the EU AI Act as artificial intelligence regulation continues to develop. The conversation also looks beyond Europe to Canada’s Bill C-8, highlighting the international nature of the regulatory challenge.

With cyber and privacy issues increasingly reaching board-level agendas, organisations need to consider not only their own cyber resilience but also the vulnerabilities created through suppliers and wider business networks.

Listen to part one

Watch part one

Audio Transcripts

Episode 11 - Part one
[0:00] Welcome to Risk Matters, the insurance podcast brought to you by DWF and your global guide to the latest trends and issues in the insurance and reinsurance industry.

[0:08] Join us as we explore topical issues, emerging technologies and the innovative strategies that are shaping the global future of insurance.

[0:19] Welcome to Risk Matters, an insurance podcast from DWF. In today's discussion, we are diving into one of the fastest moving and complex areas in modern risk, cyber and data privacy. It's a space where technology continues to evolve at pace and often outstripping the laws that are meant to regulate it. My name is Mona Hanna and I am the Canadian Chair of DWF's Cyber Privacy and Data Protection Team based out of Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Joining me today is Tim Smith, a partner in DWF's Global Risk Team based in London, UK. And as well, welcome to Stéphanie Berlan, a partner at DWF France. I don't think it's any secret that issues of cyber risk and data privacy across the globe are no longer niche IT issues. They're now critical discussion points at board meetings and amongst the C-suite of any company. Suffice to say, cyber and privacy have really moved well beyond the IT team, and are now part of the vital corporate strategy and at the heart of several, business objectives for companies. It's undeniable as well that a key driver of behavioural change is often regulation and legal compliance So with that, I'm going to get our discussion started And maybe Stephanie, you can take us through what you're seeing in France and the EU And what sort of critical changes have you been seeing with respect to the regulations? Thank you.

[1:41] Yes, thank you Mona. Hello everyone. It's true that Europe has built one of the most comprehensive and demanding digital regulatory frameworks in the world. This framework is based on multiple layers of legislation including data protection rules, AI governance, cyber security and market regulation. But for companies this has meant significant compliance costs, legal uncertainty and administrative burden, especially for international groups operating across several other states. So recognizing this, the European Commission presented in November 2025 a major reform initiative known as the Digital Omnibus with a clear political objective, simplify the framework while maintaining a high level of protection for fundamental rights. However, it's important to stress that this reform has been highly contested. European regulators and civil society organizations have warned that several proposed changes could weaken existing protections and create significant legal uncertainty, meaning that the final outcome on its radical impact for businesses remain unpredictable.

[2:49] This is a reform that is highly relevant, of course, for companies everywhere in Europe. And maybe, Tim, you can have some interesting information to give us from UK perspective. Yeah, certainly in the UK, we're really obviously very interested in what's going on in the EU.

[3:06] We're conscious of the importance of making sure that we're in step with the EU because we need to make sure that we can move data around Europe and between Europe and the UK. The things that jumped off the page in particular were the prospect of a simplification or narrowing of what was personal data and also some extra sort of.

[3:30] Finessing perhaps of the rules around subject access requests. Wearing a sort of contentious lawyer's hat, those are both potentially significant. Anything that narrows personal data down will reduce the nature and extent of any disputes. And we've certainly found that the very wide definition of data means that almost any information is caught. And we've seen sort of a bit of creep there with even sort of verbal communications being treated as personal data. The subject access requests, certainly in the UK, we found have been weaponized quite significantly. We see them used, our employment law colleagues will see them used in any kind of employment dispute. And we've also seen them used extensively in data breach cases where what we see now quite often is claimant law firms encouraging their clients to make subject access requests following a breach. So we get hundreds and hundreds of subject access requests, which plainly sort of puts a heavy burden on an entity that's already perhaps in a challenging situation.

[4:33] From a sort of litigator's perspective in the UK, those sorts of things will be really interesting. But as you said, Stephanie, I think we'd picked up that people at the European Data Protection Board were resisting the changes. So, I'd be very interested to know how you see the sort of the debate going, in Europe as to the direction of travel and where the omnibus will go given the arguments that you've identified.

[4:59] Well, I think there are two different situations. There are.

[5:05] Simplifications that have been considered as really necessary.

[5:11] Let's speak about, for instance, the consent fatigue, the fact that the cookie banners have also reached a level where people do not really understand anymore if it's probably working. So maybe there are some, yes, improvements to the EU regulation, and this does not really raise any criticism from regulators. Now, the main critics that have been raised, especially from data protection regulators, but also from data privacy organizations, is really this notion of personal data, the definition of personal data, because if you redefine the notion of personal data, of course, it's going to change a lot of things in the EU regulation. And it probably may also increase risk on the protection of the fundamental rights of the citizens. And so that's where the critics are. Of course, it's something that is requested from companies because sometimes it's really complicated, especially when it comes to DISA, as you say, teams and, the proliferation of data subject access requests and the fact that they are often used as a tool in litigation, especially in labor litigation. And believe me, in France, this is a tool that is very often used by employees.

[6:37] So there might be some improvement, but if it comes to completely redefining, what is at the core of the EU regulation, which means the very definition of personal data, this is something that is maybe more complicated. Also because it raises a new risk with the AI.

[6:59] The development of AI tools and the issue of what kind of data that can be used for AI tools and all the regulation that goes with it. And it's not the JDPR, but it's going to be the EU AI Act that will, of course, be really important in that case. So this question is maybe at the core of the discussion and it's going to be very interesting to see what will be the decision in the end. So I think, Stephanie, what I'm hearing is that our regulators, sort of across our jurisdiction, are really trying to grapple with how to effectively regulate AI while protecting individuals' privacy, all while keeping up with, you know, new and emerging tech that's being used

[7:42] in society for both good and bad. Bill C-8, which is really designed to strengthen Canada's resilience against cyber attacks for our critical infrastructure or against our critical infrastructure and for digital systems. So, for example, anything federally regulated, telecommunications, our banking industry, energy, transport, and the like. But Bill C-8, you know, effectively what it's designed to do is to, Essentially have these operators really look at their cybersecurity systems, cybersecurity protocols, making sure that they're conducting annual reviews of these programs to ensure they remain adequate in light of emerging tech.

[8:25] The Bill C-8 is also looking at managing and mitigating any risks related to third-party service providers and the supply chains. Of course, we're seeing some disruption with some recent large attacks that I think we'll probably end up chatting about at some point today.

[8:41] And of course, should a cybersecurity incident occur, Bill C-8 would add in a 72-hour reporting requirement to the regulators. And that sits in addition to the already stringent reporting requirements that they have through other legislation. So, of course, this is a bit of an advancement, I would say, and if it passes, I think it's really going to help strengthen our resilience. Notably, in Bill C-8, there's some pretty significant administrative monetary penalties and fines that are being proposed, and the numbers are like up to $15 million per day.

[9:21] For an organization and another $1 million per day for individuals. There's also, you know, a proposal in Bill C-8 for personal liability for directors and officers where they've been found to have directed, authorized, or participated in any violations and offenses. There's some criminal component of it as well. So you know, again, how do we look at achieving compliance and behavioral change? It's really adding some teeth to our legislation and I think Bill C-8 does just that.

[9:53] So on paper, I think all of these reforms have really, you know, they're seeking to promise greater transparency. They're looking at, you know, providing clarity around stronger safeguards and really doing what they can to protect individuals who are affected by cyber incidents and whatnot and cybersecurity risks.

[10:11] But while these laws are being debated and reformed, we're still seeing widespread cyber incidents. I think in the last year or so, we've seen some pretty significant ones across the globe. I'll share the experience within Canada, but what we're finding is that there's, you know, a handful of pretty nasty breaches that I think have affected, you know, millions of Canadians and millions of records. As a result of these incidents, both with and without unauthorized access to personal or confidential information, what we're seeing now is organizations turning their minds to what kind of contractual protections do they have in place? What kind of contractual liabilities do they have in place? Particularly as we have seen the prevalence of downstream incidents and incidents caused by potential service providers that are ultimately affecting an organization. You know, often this is beyond their control, but they're still pretty significantly affected.

[11:08] Tim, I want to turn the discussion over to you. I'll put you in the hot seat now. But from your vantage point, you know, hearing what I've been chatting about, you know, are you seeing sort of the same, are you sort of having the same experience here in the UK and, you know, what types of claims are you seeing? What are the trends overall that we've seen in the last year or so?

[11:30] Yeah, we're seeing a bit of everything, to be honest. It's quite an interesting dynamic because I think we've seen very large attacks where the primary target has been the huge corporate at the end. And that might be... I guess in the last year or so we've had Jaguar Land Rover, Co-op and M&S all suffer very, very significant breaches. But it's quite a mixture of attacks. And so some of the attacks have been on the entity and then had really, really significant effects on their supply chains. Jaguar Land Rover is probably, the primary one, but the other two are very significant as well. But for JLR, when you've got, I guess, it follows that car manufacturing is known for having big supply chains and the impact was clearly very significant.

[12:18] But on the other hand as well, we've had some of those attacks, the routine has been through a supplier and then up. So we've had both. And that probably creates a bit of an interesting dynamic because the larger entities aren't in a position to say they're fine and it's the small entities who represent the risk to them and that needs to be managed. It's perfectly sort of proper for the smaller entities in the supply chain to say, well, actually, you're the risk to us that you're so huge and you've got such a big footprint. Patrolling your perimeter is not straightforward. And if anything happens to you, it can have enormous consequences for us. So how the entities manage that dynamic is going to be quite interesting. A lot of it will be, I guess, straightforward commercial dynamics as to who's in the sort of power seat when it comes to driving the negotiation. Now, one might think that it's always the biggest company. But in lots of instances, those big companies might be highly dependent on particular suppliers for particular things and we used to see it very much in the IT space where in fact if you're, an IT provider whether you're a software provider or whatever quite often very small entities are crucial to the operation of the the bigger entities so it's not it doesn't follow that size is the, driver of where the discussions will land but, everyone's going to be looking at their exposure to.

[13:45] Attacks on other people and to the knock-on effects of someone in your supply chain getting hit so yeah i'd be in front just see how, that is managed and where the where it lands obviously there's an extent to which one of the things that everyone will need to be doing is looking at their supply chain, making sure that everyone's as resilient as possible that might have a good knock-on effect for people generally that everyone's going to have to up their game security wise it might mean that more people are looking at buying insurance products to to help with incident response, or just looking at how they deal with incidents and it's a response generally.

[14:23] Yeah, Stephanie, are you finding the same in France as well?

[14:27] Well, yes, there are proliferation, sorry, difficult word to say in English, proliferation, even if it's the same that in French, of cyber attacks. And we are facing this kind of incidence, at the very, at the whole part of the chain of liability, which means that, it's very complicated for the companies involved in this kind of cyber incident also to determine what has been the major failure that caused also.

[15:03] The incident and the potential data leak or data leak, existing data leak, and all the consequences that you can have also with cyber incidents, not only data leaks.

[15:16] So it's a chain of liability that is complicated to determine. We've also, we can see processes that are more and more sophisticated. And we are just at the very beginning of AI being used as a tool for this kind of attack. So this can be quite scary. And what is also complicated is that the human failure is also something that can happen. And you cannot put someone to verify what every individual is doing in an organization.

[16:01] If the policies are completely respected, because also everyone is also working, on pressure, projects are often very fast to develop. So, yes, it's a very complex situation also, of course, in France and more generally in the EU. And many studies that have been published that show that the number of attacks in every sector is increasing every day.